Here is the trade that looks like free money: an SGB tranche on the NSE quotes at Rs 11,400 when the gold it represents is worth Rs 12,000. You pay 5% below the metal, you still collect the 2.5% coupon, and if you hold it to maturity your capital gain is tax-free. Buy gold at a discount to gold. What is the catch?
There are two catches, and nobody who pitches this trade mentions either. The first is that the “2.5% coupon” is not 2.5% of what you pay, it is 2.5% of what the original buyer paid years ago, which is often half of today’s price. The second is that whether the discount actually beats a plain fresh issue depends entirely on what gold does next. The discount is real and it is worth having. It is just not the slam dunk the yield-hunters make it out to be. This post works the arithmetic to the last rupee so you can see exactly where the edge is and where it evaporates.
Why SGBs trade below gold in the first place
An SGB is a 24-karat gold claim redeemable for cash at the then-prevailing gold price, plus a 2.5% annual coupon, plus a tax-free exit at the 8-year maturity. On paper it should trade at or above the gold price it tracks. In practice most tranches on the NSE and BSE trade 3-8% below their gold-linked fair value, and the discount is widest for tranches with four or more years left to run.
The reasons are structural, not a market error:
- Thin liquidity. Daily volumes in most tranches are a handful of lots. A seller who wants out takes whatever bid exists, and the bid sits below fair value.
- Locked-in holders. Original subscribers who want to exit before year 5 can only use the exchange, and they are price-takers.
- No arbitrage mechanism. Unlike an ETF, there is no authorised participant creating or redeeming units to close the gap to NAV. The discount can persist for years.
So the discount is a genuine, repeatable feature. The question is what it is worth to you.
The setup for the math
All figures below are illustrative but built on realistic 2026 levels. I use a Rs 5,00,000 budget throughout.
- Current gold price (fair value): Rs 12,000 per gram.
- The secondary tranche: originally issued at Rs 5,000 per gram a few years ago, so it has 5 years left to its 8-year maturity. Its coupon is 2.5% of the original Rs 5,000 issue price, which is a fixed Rs 125 per gram per year, no matter what gold does.
- The fresh RBI issue (benchmark): priced at today’s Rs 12,000 per gram, 8-year maturity, coupon 2.5% of Rs 12,000, which is Rs 300 per gram per year. Note: RBI has not opened a fresh tranche since 2024, so treat this column as the reference point, not something you can buy this week.
- The gold ETF: buys at Rs 12,000 per gram equivalent, charges a 0.50% expense ratio every year, pays no coupon.
- Tax (FY 2025-26): SGB redeemed at the 8-year maturity by an individual is fully capital-gains exempt, and this applies to a secondary buyer too, as long as the bond is redeemed at maturity. The 8-year clock runs from the original issue date, not from your purchase date. Coupon income is taxed at your slab (I assume 30%). ETF gains held over 12 months are LTCG at 12.5% without indexation.
That third tax point is the whole reason this trade exists. You can buy a bond with three years left, hold it to maturity, and your entire gain is exempt even though you only owned it for three years.
The coupon trap most people walk into
Before the scenarios, kill the biggest misconception. People hear “2.5% coupon” and mentally add 2.5% to their return on the money they put in. On a secondary tranche that is wrong.
The coupon is fixed at 2.5% of the original issue price. Our tranche was issued at Rs 5,000, so it pays Rs 125 per gram per year, forever. But you are buying it at Rs 11,640 per gram (3% below the Rs 12,000 fair value). Your actual running yield on the cash you spend is:
Coupon per gram = Rs 125 (2.5% of Rs 5,000 issue price)
Your purchase price = Rs 11,640 per gram
Running coupon yield = 125 / 11,640 = 1.07% per year (pre-tax)
= about 0.75% after 30% tax
So the headline “2.5%” is really 1.07% on your money, and about 0.75% after tax. A fresh issue priced at Rs 12,000 pays Rs 300 per gram, a full 2.5% on your money. The older and more appreciated the tranche, the smaller its coupon looks relative to what you pay. This is not a reason to avoid secondary SGBs, but it is the single most mis-sold number in the whole product, and it is why the discount does not automatically win.
The three-way scenario table
Now the real comparison. Rs 5,00,000 into each option, held to maturity (or 5 years for the ETF), across three gold paths: flat, up 8% a year, down 5% a year. Coupons are taken as cash and taxed at slab, not reinvented into some optimistic reinvestment rate. The fresh RBI issue runs 8 years, the secondary tranche 5 years, so I compare the annualised return (CAGR), which is the only honest way to line up different horizons.
| Gold path | RBI fresh issue (8yr, par) | Secondary (5yr, 3% discount) | Gold ETF (5yr) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flat (0%/yr) | Rs 5,70,000 / 1.65% | Rs 5,34,300 / 1.33% | Rs 4,87,600 / -0.50% |
| Up 8%/yr | Rs 9,95,500 / 8.99% | Rs 7,76,200 / 9.20% | Rs 6,89,400 / 6.63% |
| Down 5%/yr | Rs 4,01,700 / -2.70% | Rs 4,17,600 / -3.54% | Rs 3,77,300 / -5.47% |
Read it carefully, because it does not say what the pitch says.
The ETF loses everywhere. Both SGB routes beat the gold ETF in every single scenario, by 1.5 to 2.9 percentage points a year. That gap is the coupon plus the tax-free maturity minus the ETF’s expense ratio and its 12.5% LTCG bill. If your real choice is “SGB or ETF,” the SGB wins and it is not close. This is the robust, boring, correct conclusion.
The discount does not automatically beat a fresh issue. Look at the flat and down scenarios: the fresh RBI issue (1.65% and -2.70%) actually beats the discounted secondary tranche (1.33% and -3.54%). Why? Because the fresh issue pays a Rs 300 coupon versus the tranche’s Rs 125, and when gold is flat or falling, that fat fixed coupon matters more than a one-time 3% price discount spread over five years. The discount only pulls ahead when gold rises (9.20% versus 8.99% in the up case), because then your extra grams, bought cheap, compound.
So the honest headline is: a secondary discount is worth chasing when you are bullish on gold, and a fresh issue’s higher coupon is better when you expect gold to go sideways or down. Since fresh issues are not currently available, the practical point is that the discount is a bonus on an already-good instrument, not a reason to overpay in effort or spread to grab one.
Isolating what the discount alone is worth
To value the discount cleanly, strip out the coupon difference and compare the same tranche bought at fair value versus at a 3% discount. Same Rs 125 coupon, same 5-year maturity, same gold path. The only variable is the entry price.
| Gold path | Secondary at par (0% disc) | Secondary at 3% discount | Annualised uplift |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flat | 0.72% | 1.33% | +61 bps |
| Up 8%/yr | 8.53% | 9.20% | +67 bps |
| Down 5%/yr | -4.12% | -3.54% | +58 bps |
A 3% entry discount is worth roughly 60 basis points a year over a 5-year hold. That is a real, free pickup for doing nothing but buying on the exchange instead of at par. It is not life-changing, but over Rs 5 lakh and five years it is about Rs 16,000 of extra value, and it compounds if the tranche is larger or the discount is deeper.
The discount boost shrinks the longer the tranche runs
Here is the counterintuitive bit that the “discounts are biggest on long-dated tranches” crowd gets backwards. A fixed percentage discount captured at maturity is an IRR, and an IRR spread over more years is a smaller annual number. The discount from a deeply discounted 7-year tranche annualises to less per year than the same discount on a 2-year tranche, because you wait longer to collect it.
This table shows the pure annualised return from the discount alone (flat gold, so you see only the discount effect):
| Years to maturity | 3% discount | 5% discount | 8% discount |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 years | 1.53%/yr | 2.60%/yr | 4.28%/yr |
| 4 years | 0.76%/yr | 1.29%/yr | 2.11%/yr |
| 5 years | 0.61%/yr | 1.03%/yr | 1.69%/yr |
| 7 years | 0.44%/yr | 0.73%/yr | 1.20%/yr |
Two things fall out of this. First, the figure you sometimes see quoted, that a 5% discount adds only “35-40 bps” of yield, is too low for the tranches retail investors actually buy: a 5% discount with 5 years left is worth about 103 bps a year, and with 4 years left, about 129 bps. The understated figure assumes a much longer runway than an 8-year bond can offer. Second, for pure yield pickup you want a short-dated, deeply discounted tranche, not the longest one on the screen. A 2-year tranche at an 8% discount throws off a 4.28% annualised boost because you capture the gap fast and reach the tax-free line sooner.
The catch, of course, is that a shorter tranche gives you fewer years of tax-free gold exposure and fewer coupons. So the real optimisation is: if you want gold exposure for the long haul, a long discounted tranche is fine, but do not pretend the discount is adding a huge yield; if you specifically want to harvest the discount, buy short-dated tranches trading cheap and let them mature.
The execution details that quietly eat the edge
A 60 bps edge is thin enough that sloppy execution can erase it. Watch these:
- Bid-ask spread. Thin tranches quote with a 1-2% spread. If you cross the spread to buy, you have already given back a chunk of your discount. Use limit orders, and be patient.
- The discount you see may be stale. Screen prices can lag the live gold price by hours in an illiquid tranche. Compute fair value yourself: grams per unit times current gold price. Only then do you know the true discount.
- Accrued coupon. The exchange price is effectively a dirty price near a coupon record date. Whoever holds on the record date gets the full half-yearly coupon, so buying just before it is slightly better than just after, though the amounts are small.
- Odd lots and liquidity on exit. If you ever need to sell before maturity you face the same thin market, now as a seller. The discount that helped you buy will hurt you when you sell. The trade only makes sense if you genuinely intend to hold to maturity.
- Demat only. Secondary SGBs sit in your demat account. No paper, no bank-branch exit. Fine for most, worth knowing.
When this trade is actually right
Put the pieces together and the decision is clean:
| Your situation | What to do |
|---|---|
| Choice is SGB versus gold ETF | Buy the secondary SGB. It wins in every gold scenario here. |
| You want a target gold allocation and SGBs are the vehicle | Buy on the exchange, not at par. The 3% discount is a free ~60 bps/yr. |
| You are specifically hunting yield from the discount | Prefer short-dated tranches trading cheap; the discount annualises higher. |
| You might need to exit before maturity | Reconsider. The exit discount can wipe out the entry discount. ETF is more liquid. |
| You are bearish on gold and a fresh issue is available | The fresh issue’s 2.5% coupon beats a discount when gold is flat or falling. |
Bottom line
Buying SGBs on the secondary market at a 3-8% discount is a legitimately good trade, but for the right reason. The discount itself is worth roughly 60 basis points a year on a typical 3%-off, 5-year tranche, and more on shorter or deeper-discounted ones. The bigger prize is simpler and more robust: a secondary SGB held to maturity beats a gold ETF in every scenario here, because the coupon and the tax-free redemption together outrun the ETF’s expense ratio and its 12.5% LTCG bill. What the discount does not do is make the “2.5% coupon” real for you, that number is 2.5% of some old issue price and nearer to 1% on the cash you actually spend, so do not double-count it. Buy with limit orders, compute the true discount against live gold yourself, and only do this if you mean to hold to maturity. Do that and you own gold a few percent below the metal, with a tax-free finish line, which is about the best structural deal Indian retail gold investing still offers.
All figures here are illustrative, based on representative 2026 gold levels and current tax rules, and are not investment advice. Your actual tranche, its issue price and coupon, the live discount, your tax slab, and future gold prices will move every number above.
Comments