Every portability guide tells you the same reassuring thing: when you switch health insurers, IRDAI rules force the new company to credit the waiting period you have already served, so your pre-existing disease (PED) clock does not restart. True, and genuinely valuable. But it is also the part that distracts you from the expensive part.
Here is what almost nobody puts a number on. Your No Claim Bonus (NCB) - the free extra cover you earned by not claiming, which can quietly turn a Rs. 5 lakh base policy into Rs. 7.5 lakh of effective cover - does not port in most cases. At a large share of Indian insurers it resets to zero the moment you switch. So you can chase a Rs. 4,000-a-year cheaper premium and unknowingly hand back Rs. 2.5 lakh of accumulated cover to do it.
That is not an argument against porting. It is an argument for pricing the port properly before you sign. Let me do the math.
The two things that happen when you port
IRDAI’s portability framework (the Health Insurance Regulations and the portability guidelines) gives you one strong protection and leaves one big hole.
What you keep - waiting period credit. The new insurer must give you credit for the time already served against waiting periods. If your old policy had a 3-year PED waiting period and you completed 2 years, the new insurer can only impose 1 more year, not a fresh 3. Same logic for the initial 30-day waiting period and specific-ailment waits. This is the whole reason porting is viable at all - without it, switching would reset you to a brand-new customer medically.
What you usually lose - the accumulated NCB. This is where the marketing goes quiet. The waiting-period credit is on the base sum insured and the time served. The NCB you built up is extra sum insured sitting on top of the base, and most insurers do not carry it over when you port in. A few will match or credit it as a goodwill or underwriting decision, but you cannot assume it. Treat the NCB as lost unless the new insurer puts the carry-over in writing in your policy schedule.
So the honest mental model of a port is: you keep your medical seniority, you often lose your earned bonus.
What the NCB is actually worth
A No Claim Bonus increases your sum insured for every claim-free year, at no extra premium. The two common structures:
- Cumulative bonus: typically +10% of base sum insured per claim-free year, capped at 50% (some plans go to 100%).
- Accelerated / high bonus: +50% per claim-free year, capped at 100% or more, on plans that market this feature.
Take the common case: a Rs. 5 lakh family floater with a 10%-per-year cumulative bonus capped at 50%. After five claim-free years:
| Claim-free years completed | NCB added | Effective sum insured |
|---|---|---|
| 0 (new policy) | 0% | Rs. 5,00,000 |
| 1 | 10% | Rs. 5,50,000 |
| 2 | 20% | Rs. 6,00,000 |
| 3 | 30% | Rs. 6,50,000 |
| 4 | 40% | Rs. 7,00,000 |
| 5 | 50% (cap) | Rs. 7,50,000 |
That Rs. 2,50,000 on top of the base is real cover. You could claim the full Rs. 7.5 lakh on a bad hospitalisation year. And you paid nothing extra for it - it was the reward for five quiet years.
Port to a new insurer who zeroes the NCB, and your effective cover drops from Rs. 7.5 lakh back to Rs. 5 lakh on day one. You are now paying premium for a smaller ceiling than you had the week before.
How long to rebuild the bonus you surrendered
The cost of the reset is not just “Rs. 2.5 lakh of cover gone today.” It is that you have to earn it all over again, slowly, and only if you stay claim-free. At +10% per year with a 50% cap, rebuilding from zero to the old level takes a full five claim-free years - and that assumes nobody in a family of four needs to make even one claim in that window.
| After porting | NCB rebuilt | Effective cover | Gap vs pre-port Rs. 7.5L |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | 10% | Rs. 5,50,000 | Rs. 2,00,000 short |
| Year 2 | 20% | Rs. 6,00,000 | Rs. 1,50,000 short |
| Year 3 | 30% | Rs. 6,50,000 | Rs. 1,00,000 short |
| Year 4 | 40% | Rs. 7,00,000 | Rs. 50,000 short |
| Year 5 | 50% | Rs. 7,50,000 | Back to even |
For a family of four, five straight claim-free years is optimistic. One appendicitis, one maternity-adjacent hospitalisation, one child’s dengue admission, and the NCB clock either freezes or steps back (many policies reduce the bonus by one slab, i.e. 10 percentage points, after a claim rather than wiping it fully). So in practice the realistic time to get back to a 50% bonus after porting is often longer than five years. You are not borrowing the Rs. 2.5 lakh for five years - you may be giving up a chunk of it indefinitely.
The breakeven: premium saved vs cover surrendered
Now put the two numbers against each other properly. The port is usually motivated by a cheaper premium. The question is whether the saving justifies walking away from the NCB.
Assume a family of four (two adults ~38, two children) on a Rs. 5 lakh floater that has built up to a 50% NCB (Rs. 7.5 lakh effective). Representative 2026 numbers, illustrative, not quotes:
| Item | Current insurer | New (ported) insurer |
|---|---|---|
| Base sum insured | Rs. 5,00,000 | Rs. 5,00,000 |
| Accumulated NCB | Rs. 2,50,000 (50%) | Rs. 0 (reset) |
| Effective cover | Rs. 7,50,000 | Rs. 5,00,000 |
| Annual premium | Rs. 32,000 | Rs. 28,000 |
| Annual saving on port | - | Rs. 4,000 |
You save Rs. 4,000 a year. You give up Rs. 2,50,000 of effective cover on day one, and you forgo the NCB growth you would otherwise have kept on the old policy.
There are two honest ways to value what you lost.
Breakeven 1 - cash saving vs cover surrendered. The naive framing: Rs. 4,000 saved per year against Rs. 2,50,000 of cover given up. It takes 62.5 years of premium savings to “buy back” Rs. 2.5 lakh of cover at Rs. 4,000 a year. That framing overstates it, because sum insured is not cash - you only lose it if you actually have a claim above Rs. 5 lakh. But it anchors the scale: the surrendered cover dwarfs the saving.
Breakeven 2 - cost to replace the lost cover. The fairer framing. What does it cost to rebuild that Rs. 2.5 lakh of cover you just lost? The cleanest replacement is a super top-up - cheap, high-ceiling cover that sits above a deductible. A Rs. 5 lakh deductible, Rs. 20 lakh super top-up for this family runs roughly Rs. 6,000-7,000 a year. But you would arguably want that anyway. The narrower like-for-like question is: the saving is Rs. 4,000; the thing you gave up (NCB) would have cost you nothing to keep. So the port’s true price is:
Net benefit of porting in year 1
= premium saved - value of cover surrendered
= Rs. 4,000 - (cover you now have to self-insure or rebuild)
If you value the lost Rs. 2.5 lakh of headroom at even a modest Rs. 5,000-6,000 of equivalent top-up premium to replace, the port is net negative in year 1 - you saved Rs. 4,000 and took on Rs. 5,000-6,000 of replacement cost to get back to where you were. The Rs. 4,000 saving does not clear the bar.
When the port is clearly worth it anyway
The NCB reset is a real cost, not a veto. Port when the reason is bigger than a few thousand rupees of premium:
- Your current insurer has a bad claim-settlement record or repeatedly loads your renewal. A Rs. 2.5 lakh NCB on a policy that fights every claim is worth less than a clean Rs. 5 lakh with an insurer that pays. Porting to escape a poor claims experience beats the bonus math easily.
- The new insurer carries over the NCB in writing. Some insurers do credit the accumulated bonus on port-in as an underwriting decision. If you get it in the policy schedule, the reset cost disappears and only the premium saving remains. Always ask, and get it documented before you cancel the old policy.
- You are upgrading the base sum insured itself. If you are porting from a Rs. 5 lakh to a Rs. 15 lakh base, the larger base swamps the lost Rs. 2.5 lakh NCB. The reset stings less when the new ceiling is far higher regardless.
- Your old plan has structurally bad features - low room-rent caps, mandatory co-pay, disease sub-limits, no restoration benefit. Escaping a Rs. 5 lakh policy that only effectively pays Rs. 2 lakh after sub-limits is worth losing a nominal NCB.
- You port before you ever need to claim, and you can rebuild quietly. A young, healthy family with low claim probability can afford five claim-free years to rebuild. The reset is a paper loss they will likely recover.
When to stay put
Do not port when the only reason is a modest premium saving and your current policy is fine:
- You have a large, hard-won NCB (40-50%) and a clean policy. The accumulated cover is worth more than Rs. 4,000 a year. Stay.
- Someone in the family has an active or recent condition. Even with waiting-period credit, a new insurer re-underwrites you at port-in and can decline, load, or exclude. A reset NCB plus a fresh exclusion is the worst of both worlds. Do not disturb a policy that is already covering a condition.
- You are mid-way through a PED waiting period and the new insurer is slow or disputes the credit. The credit is your right, but a messy transfer at renewal time can leave a gap. If the saving is small, the risk is not worth it.
The one timing rule that matters
If you are going to port, port at renewal, before you have a claim, and never with an open or recent claim. A fresh claim resets or reduces your NCB anyway and makes the new insurer underwrite you harder. And start the port process at least 45 days before your renewal date - IRDAI requires you to apply for portability ahead of renewal, and a late application simply will not go through, forcing you to either renew with the old insurer or risk a coverage gap.
Bottom line
Porting your health policy keeps your waiting-period seniority - that part of the pitch is true and it is the reason porting exists. But at most insurers it quietly resets your No Claim Bonus to zero, and for a family that has built a 50% NCB on a Rs. 5 lakh floater, that is Rs. 2.5 lakh of effective cover gone on day one, taking a realistic five-plus claim-free years to rebuild. Against that, a Rs. 4,000-a-year premium saving does not clear the bar: valued as replacement cover, the port is roughly break-even to net-negative in year one. So port for a real reason - a bad claims record, punitive loadings, structurally weak features, a genuine base-cover upgrade, or a written NCB carry-over - not to shave a few thousand rupees. If your current policy pays claims cleanly and you hold a large bonus, the boring move of staying put is usually the richer one. And whenever you do port, do it at renewal, well before any claim, with the application in at least 45 days early.
Figures here are illustrative representative 2026 ranges, not quotes, and vary by insurer, age, city, and policy wording. This is general information, not investment or insurance advice. Confirm NCB carry-over and waiting-period credit in writing before you cancel any existing policy.
Comments